Saturday, July 31, 2010

For CBI, slander is evidence!


Real target of Congress' Goebbelsian propaganda is Narendra Modi!

There have been more than 5,000 ‘encounter deaths’ in this country. Over 1,700 ‘encounter death’-related complaints are pending in various courts and before the Human Rights Commission. More than 800 ‘encounter deaths’ took place in the last few decades in Uttar Pradesh alone. More than 400 police ‘encounters’ took place in Maharashtra. None of these (incidents) has come to trial as has the Sohrabuddin case. We have never heard that anyone has been convicted for these thousands of ‘encounter deaths’. No policemen have been found guilty or even arrested as it has happened in Gujarat,” says Mr Devang Nanavati, an Ahmedabad-based lawyer who is associated with the BJP, while highlighting the strange obsession with which the death of a notorious criminal who had a mile-long record of serious crimes and whose links with Dawood Ibrahim qualified him as a terror accomplice, is being pursued by the Congress, the Central Bureau of Investigation, congenital liars who pose as human rights activists and a corrosive media which has lost all sense of balance and fair play.

The Supreme Court, which asked the CBI to inquire into the ‘larger conspiracy’ behind the killing of Sohrabuddin Shaikh and his wife, Kauser Bi, nearly five years after the incident had occurred, was no doubt motivated by the noble intention of getting to the truth. However, such lofty intentions need not necessarily be attributed to the sustained pressure from the slain criminal’s apparently inconsolable brother and jholawallahs who would be rendered jobless (and thus find themselves starved of generous funding by a variety of sources and agencies) if society were to be cleansed of malcontent, to punish those responsible for what they allege to be extrajudicial killings carried out by the police on the instructions of BJP leaders. Their pre-determination of guilt, both by implication and association, which finds more than an echo in what the CBI now alleges through stories which are touted as ‘investigative journalism’ by newspapers and news channels whose bias renders them incapable of distinguishing between fact and fiction, cannot be allowed to supplant the judicial process.

Events over the past fortnight have removed all doubts, if there were any, about the CBI’s motives that are anything but lofty. The agency has been most brazen while pursuing a political agenda set by the Congress to defame Chief Minister Narendra Modi through slander and worse with the sole purpose of tarring his reputation and hobbling his Government to a point where it begins to lose credibility among Gujarat’s voters. For, the real target of the Goebbelsian propaganda orchestrated by the Congress with the help of the CBI and a craven media is not Mr Amit Shah, who has resigned as Minister of State for Home after being charged with murder, extortion and obstruction of justice in the Sohrabuddin ‘false’ encounter case and is currently in jail. It is Mr Modi — his invincibility is being sought to be weakened. At the national level, the purpose is to force the BJP on the back foot and tie it down to answering allegations instead of leading a robust campaign to oust the Congress from power.

The use of manufactured taint to stun and paralyse political foes is nothing new for the Congress; it’s a past master at the game of misusing agencies of the state, most notably the Intelligence Bureau and the CBI, to further its political interests. When the Congress needed to put down the Raja of Amethi Sanjay Singh after he fell out with Rajiv Gandhi, it used the CBI, which was inquiring into the murder of badminton champion Syed Modi in 1988, to plant salacious stories in newspapers — there were no 24x7 news channels those days — eager to oblige the party. ‘Excerpts’ from what was alleged to be the personal diary of Syed Modi’s widow, Amita, found their way into the front page of these newspapers day after day, suitably embellished with insinuations and slanderous concoctions attributed to ‘sources’ in the CBI. Public memory being proverbially short, few people would remember today that the charges against Mr Sanjay Singh and Ms Amita Modi did not stick — the courts contemptuously threw them out. Twenty-one years later, the CBI quietly closed the case, having failed to establish the ‘larger conspiracy’ behind Syed Modi’s murder which, not surprisingly, it had claimed to have established in 1988-89.

Nor would too many people remember the so-called ‘St Kitts scandal’ that was manufactured by the Congress with the help of an obliging CBI to embarrass VP Singh and divert attention from the Bofors bribery scandal in 1989. An elaborate exercise was undertaken to forge documents to allege that VP Singh was a beneficiary of his son Ajeya’s ‘offshore account’ in First Trust Corp, a little-known bank in St Kitts of which nobody had heard till then. The forged documents showed that the account contained $ 21 million. Once again, eager-to-oblige newspapers published the bogus story and the Congress’s dirty tricks department had a field day painting VP Singh in the most lurid of colours, pronouncing him as a villain who was not quite the knight in shining armour that people thought he was. In the end, of course, the forgery was exposed, the conspiracy to defame VP Singh unravelled and the Congress lost the general election. Similarly, the Congress had tried to frame Mr LK Advani in the so-called ‘hawala case’ on the eve of the general election in 1996. Not only did the Congress lose that election but Mr Advani — and the BJP — emerged stronger from that attempt to sully his and the party’s image.

Examples of the Congress misusing the CBI abound. It is no secret that after the UPA came to power in the summer of 2004, the agency not only ensured Ottavio Quattrocchi remained at a safe distance from India where he was wanted to stand trial in the Bofors bribery case in which he was the prime accused, but also facilitated the emptying of the London bank accounts where the bribe money had been parked by the Italian middleman. Subsequently, the case was ‘closed’, much to the relief of a Prime Minister who actually believed prosecuting those behind the Bofors scandal was “a shame”. We also know how the CBI’s investigations into the disproportionate assets cases against Ms Mayawati and Mr Mulayam Singh Yadav are used to secure their support for the Government at moments of crisis.

In the Sohrabuddin ‘false’ encounter case, the CBI is back to using its old trick of planting stories about ‘evidence’ that has been clearly concocted to suit the Congress’s insidious gameplan. The fact is, it has filed a chargesheet but has no evidence to substantiate its allegations. And so the CBI has sought more time from the Supreme Court for ‘investigation’. Doesn’t prosecution follow investigation? Or is it the other way round for the Congress Bureau of Intimidation? And is that why it wants the case transferred out of Gujarat?

[This appeared as my Sunday column, Coffee Break, in The Pioneer on August 1, 2010.]

23 comments:

Ankit said...

You forgot the dilution of cases against Laloo Yadav,Mayawati and Mulayam to get their support in Parliament.

ashwani said...

the supreme c****ia's of india are basically responsible for this macabre drama being enacted for the benefit for the decreipit ruling family of india.i'm very sure that these supreme c****ia's of india are surely receiving big kickbacks/promises/favours for their services in this scandal.already some info has been put out about on of these fudges being cleared by cbi in the pf scam case.

raj said...

These corrupt congress and the equally corrupt CBI has been doing this type of jobs for the anti nationals all over India. We will see the congress building a stupa in memory of the slain anti national Shohrabuddin. The way the congress is using CBI, it can be perceived that they have lost all hope for winning the elections in Gujarath. They are now playing for the larger public of Bihar and other states which are going into election mode who will gobble down what ever the coteries of Italian Mama Mia and her family Abhishek Manu Singvi vomits in public platform.

sk said...

congress was and is a fascist party.with media in its pocket itis trying to bring emergency byother means earller it wasMISA NOW CBI.see how it is blackmailing mayawati and mulayam to serve the interests of dynasty.

Prashant said...

During cut motion how they used CBI against Lalu Mulayam or even Maya.... Actually they are in power because of सीबीआईia

Anonymous said...

Hi! Kanchan,

Why don't you contest election and make a difference. Pick up a small city or county in West Bengal and go ahead. It is very easy to write blogs with fire and ice, there are challanges to run this country. Why does'nt BJP, the party that you advocate, as an responsible opposition come up with solutions rather than bandh, dharnas, and other drama. Atlease congress does not handover terrorists on a platter to their country men. India is going through a growth phase that would attract inflation due to demand supply gap and thus would induce crime. How many BJP run legislatives have actually reviewed crime reports in their constituency and responded with plan of actions. Your jounalism looks like a anti congress mouth piece and nothing else.

sunaath said...

Not only the CBI, the Governors of various states also act like the agents of the Congress to malign and harass the non-Congress governments in different states. The drama going on in Karnataka is an example.

Indian Nationalist said...

whats ur point Mr. Kanchan Gupta?. You can keep whining and crying and what not but unless and until the Hindus of this country firm up and get some self-respect for themselves and that includes the BJP/RSS then nothing will change.

Madam Sonia along with her kids are away abroad for the past 1 week and nobody knows where she has gone. Why is the BJP not raising this issue on the public platform?.

This makes me think that the BJP is a part of the Congress strategy.

senthil said...

but kanchanda.. even you are not able to name the italian queen behind this entire episode..

In my view, the current inquisition against Modi and Gujarat, is because, few months back, Modi dared to target Sonia Gandhi asking for explanation for the bofors debacle..

As a means to silence Modi, and as an warning to others on what will happen if they even think of Sonia's names in public, the entire prosecution is carried in such a vigorous manner..

I am really surprised that even you have so much hesitation in naming the mastermind...

In short, this entire episode is a witch hunt and an inquisition..

Earlier, they tried through SIT to bring down Modi, but they could not..

No wonder, there would be backstabbers within BJP who can silently work against Modi..

Anonymous said...

@Ashwani , Do you know who what job last Chief justice of Supreme C$%$# is doing now? i suppose he got it for supporting Kangress party

Anonymous said...

Mr Gupta ... please please please watch this ... http://deshgujarat.com/2010/07/31/whole-sohrabuddincbi-plot-was-cooked-at-ahmed-patels-bungalow-i-witnessed-it/


Get it translated by someone who knows gujarati ... it is pretty straight forward .... Please spread the word

InternetHindu said...

Sir, what the BJP is losing out is simple. It has to highlight HOW cong is using CBI to intervene in the investigation. You have to quote by examples as to how cong has been active in turning the case to its political benefits, without which the common man will never the BJP as to how any super PM can control a Supreme Court directed enquiry.
You have to make it clear to the BJP that they have to exactly talk about these and dramatize every step of cong in interfering with investigation. While watching some talk shows on 24X7 news channels it is evident that BJP is not moving ahead of pointing out the amount of influence spent in bending directions of the processes in and outside courts.

K said...

I have been usually following your tweets and came across this article. Your writings does not give any unbiased journalism approach but an indication that its nothing more than a BJP mouthpiece or I should say anti congress publicity. There are issues in Gujarat & MP where BJP is ruling and I have never found any comments against them. So in short, are you a journo or just another opposition mouth piece doing a fault finding with ruling party rather than doing anything good for the country.... not sure if this gets through your moderation but would be great if you atleast read it.
And yes, get a conscience.

Kanchan Gupta said...

Ankit: Well, I have mentioned how CBI cases against Mayawati and Mulayam are being used by the Congress to secure their support in Parliament.

Kanchan Gupta said...

Anonymous: At least I do not hide behind 'Anonymity'. I am upfront. And I would praise the Congress if it did anything good. I have in the past praised individual Ministers in the Government. As for contesting elections, well, thanks for the suggestion.

Kanchan Gupta said...

K: From your perspective, it's not fair to criticise the Congress. I am sure you have your reasons. You are entitled to your opinion. As for 'issues' in MP and Gujarat, I am quite well acquainted with both the States as I am with States where the Congress or its allies are in power. Why don't you take the lead by looking at 'issues' in the States where the Congress and/or its allies are in power? By the way, people with strong views should use their name while posting comments. Anonymity weakens your case.

Rakesh Singh - राकेश सिंह said...

Kanchan Da, brilliant article. Where ever serious law and order problem were there, it was MAINLY controlled by fake encounters. As you pointed out, there are plenty of examples of fake encounters. Take the example of Jamshedpur (Dr. Ajay Kumar as SP), there were at least a dozen fake encounters by police under the guidance of Ajay Kumar & Lalu Yadav to control the criminals. All Jamshedpur people know the GOOD results of those fake encounters.

When criminals can’t/or are not being punished by our law then there is no other way (for police) except fake encounter to improve law & order.

Sohrabuddin case is no different than other fake encounter in other parts of country. Its crystal clear that Congress is using CBI to target Modi. I see a bigger problem, now police will not be willing to kill criminals by fake encounter. With out fake encounter its almost IMPOSSIBLE to control criminals like Sohrabuddin.

M. Patil said...

Kanchan,

I think honest journo's like you must scrutinize not just the CBI but also the judiciary. There is a lot of judicial corruption too. BJP should wonder if there was any 'quid pro quo' for ordering probes against its party in Gujarat.

Lets not forget SC Justice Ahmadi diluted the charges against Union Carbide and later after retirement became chairman of the hospital funded by none other than Carbide!

How did exceptionally corrupt Dinakaran became HC Justice in Karnataka and later got to be nominated to be the SC Justice?

This entire post retirement sinecures reek of corruption.

http://deshgujarat.com/2010/08/01/judge-who-ordered-cbi-probe-in-sohrab-case-himself-under-cbi-scanner-for-corruption/

Anonymous said...

"Atlease congress does not handover terrorists on a platter to their country men" - what a joke? Is handing over half of Kashmir and Manasarovar to China is not enough? It is the same Congress which instigated mass hysteria by the family members of those hijacked to put pressure on Govt of India to release terrorists. These comments and people make me feel that there is no future for this country. They will only wakeup when one day Talibanis will rule India and then it will be too late.

surajcap said...

Out Nitin Gadkari now or he will destroy Hindu BJP
Shame on him, who could do nothing on Ram Janmabhoomi or ousting illegal Bangladeshis from BJP ruled (with allies) states while talking of Muslim rights - next he will say Kashi-Mathura-Dhar Temples are Mosques! No wonder afterall he is a Congressi Agent - http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/How-a-Cong-trade-union-leader-became-BJP-chief/articleshow/6198337.cms
Other BJP leader trying to bring down Modi in fear
Hence, not highlighting these. Actually inefficient current BJP leaders fear Modi & his popularity so colluding with Congress!

BJP need new Hindutva leaders as under for revival! Current Topbrass failed us in every issue from ousting Bangladeshis to building Ram Mandir and can't even counter Congress on Kashmir, Inflation, Kasab, Afzal, etc so we must have change soon or see repeat of 2004 & 2009!
1) PM Candidate - Narendra Modi
2) National President - Govindacharya (after returning him)
3) National Vice-Presidents - Vinay Katiyar/Yogi Adityanath/Dileep Singh Judeo
4) National Youth (BJYM) President - Varun Gandhi
5) General Secretaries - Arun Jaitley/Sushma Swaraj/Uma Bharti (returned)
6) Next Presidential Candidate - Kalyan Singh (must be returned)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jan_Kranti_Party
Also, BJP who talk of cultural nationalism but has no cultural agenda, must update its objectives as these:-
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hindu_Munnani#Objectives
http://hindumunnani.org/objective.asp
Ram Mandir Movement along with ousting illegal Bangladeshis and liberating Kashi-Mathura-Dhar be undertaken to revive BJP in largest state Uttar Pradesh.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ram_Janmabhoomi
This can be achieved only if Kalraj Mishra is returned as UP BJP President since Mayavati otherwise will get all Brahmin votes! Similiarly, all out effort needed in intellectual revolution like negating these -
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indo-Aryan_migration

Must decide whether we are Hindu first or Indian!?

Demand bans on Bible & Koran as against Indian Constitution and promotes violence -
http://hindunationalismmuslimunity.blogspot.com/2009/10/indian-govt-gives-taxpayer-money-in.html
India changed many times and in reality is land of Hindus so when Muslims became majority we lost Islamic Bangladesh & Pakistan and if Hindus became concentrated to Delhi alone ousted from other places like Kashmir, Assam or West Bengal (as happening now by crores of illegal Muslim infiltrators from neighbouring nations) then Delhi will be called India so India is nothing but Hindusthan and Hindu is the cause and India the effect so without Hindu majority there will be no India but a larger Pakistan!
http://hindusamhati.org
While Hindus call anyone championing their rights as communal the Muslims have never been known to expose and help arrest Jihadis and infiltrators hiding in their ghettos in towns and villages of India, rather explosives and weapons seized from mosques -
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/India/Explosives-weapons-seized-near-Kerala-mosque/articleshow/6160395.cms
Now Sickular NDTV accepted Sohrabuddin as Criminal but lazy BJP leaders can't say these in media and do protest:
http://www.ndtv.com/article/india/who-was-sohrabuddin-sheikh-39280
Speak up first against Gang Rapist Rahul Gandhi as law should be equal for all -
http://rahulgandhirapessukanya.blogspot.com/
http://biharnews2k1.hypermart.net/20020228_champa_biswas.htm
http://www.petitiononline.com/rahulrap/petition.html
Or India will be in danger: http://www.hindurashtra.org/bangla_infiltration.wmv
Congress did several encounters in Maharashtra, etc against criminals but Congress funded media silent on them that be exoposed to counter Amit-Shorabuddin case!

Horrific attack by illegal Bangladeshi Muslims in east India leaves 2,00,000 Hindu Bodos are refugee in Assam while similar persecution in West Bengal continues unabated in CPM-TMC alliance:
http://bengalspotlight.blogspot.com

surajcap said...

Out Nitin Gadkari now or he will destroy Hindu BJP
Shame on him, who could do nothing on Ram Janmabhoomi or ousting illegal Bangladeshis from BJP ruled (with allies) states while talking of Muslim rights - next he will say Kashi-Mathura-Dhar Temples are Mosques! No wonder afterall he is a Congressi Agent - http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/How-a-Cong-trade-union-leader-became-BJP-chief/articleshow/6198337.cms
Other BJP leader trying to bring down Modi in fear
Hence, not highlighting these. Actually inefficient current BJP leaders fear Modi & his popularity so colluding with Congress!

BJP need new Hindutva leaders as under for revival! Current Topbrass failed us in every issue from ousting Bangladeshis to building Ram Mandir and can't even counter Congress on Kashmir, Inflation, Kasab, Afzal, etc so we must have change soon or see repeat of 2004 & 2009!
1) PM Candidate - Narendra Modi
2) National President - Govindacharya (after returning him)
3) National Vice-Presidents - Vinay Katiyar/Yogi Adityanath/Dileep Singh Judeo
4) National Youth (BJYM) President - Varun Gandhi
5) General Secretaries - Arun Jaitley/Sushma Swaraj/Uma Bharti (returned)
6) Next Presidential Candidate - Kalyan Singh (must be returned)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jan_Kranti_Party
Also, BJP who talk of cultural nationalism but has no cultural agenda, must update its objectives as these:-
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hindu_Munnani#Objectives
http://hindumunnani.org/objective.asp
Ram Mandir Movement along with ousting illegal Bangladeshis and liberating Kashi-Mathura-Dhar be undertaken to revive BJP in largest state Uttar Pradesh.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ram_Janmabhoomi
This can be achieved only if Kalraj Mishra is returned as UP BJP President since Mayavati otherwise will get all Brahmin votes! Similiarly, all out effort needed in intellectual revolution like negating these -
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indo-Aryan_migration

Must decide whether we are Hindu first or Indian!?

Demand bans on Bible & Koran as against Indian Constitution and promotes violence -
http://hindunationalismmuslimunity.blogspot.com/2009/10/indian-govt-gives-taxpayer-money-in.html
India changed many times and in reality is land of Hindus so when Muslims became majority we lost Islamic Bangladesh & Pakistan and if Hindus became concentrated to Delhi alone ousted from other places like Kashmir, Assam or West Bengal (as happening now by crores of illegal Muslim infiltrators from neighbouring nations) then Delhi will be called India so India is nothing but Hindusthan and Hindu is the cause and India the effect so without Hindu majority there will be no India but a larger Pakistan!
http://hindusamhati.org
While Hindus call anyone championing their rights as communal the Muslims have never been known to expose and help arrest Jihadis and infiltrators hiding in their ghettos in towns and villages of India, rather explosives and weapons seized from mosques -
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/India/Explosives-weapons-seized-near-Kerala-mosque/articleshow/6160395.cms
Now Sickular NDTV accepted Sohrabuddin as Criminal but lazy BJP leaders can't say these in media and do protest:
http://www.ndtv.com/article/india/who-was-sohrabuddin-sheikh-39280
Speak up first against Gang Rapist Rahul Gandhi as law should be equal for all -
http://rahulgandhirapessukanya.blogspot.com/
http://biharnews2k1.hypermart.net/20020228_champa_biswas.htm
http://www.petitiononline.com/rahulrap/petition.html
Or India will be in danger: http://www.hindurashtra.org/bangla_infiltration.wmv
Congress did several encounters in Maharashtra, etc against criminals but Congress funded media silent on them that be exoposed to counter Amit-Shorabuddin case!

Horrific attack by illegal Bangladeshi Muslims in east India leaves 2,00,000 Hindu Bodos are refugee in Assam while similar persecution in West Bengal continues unabated in CPM-TMC alliance:
http://bengalspotlight.blogspot.com

Anonymous said...

When I saw tehelka tapes was shocked & wrote Modi & others have to face interrogation. Narendra Modi sharing the platform with Nithyananda was another jolt.

But why tehelka does not show stones pelting & butchery of hindus by muslims in such graphic detail ?

That Jagannathan who was mercilessly killed by a group of muslims in a ship to vent out their " cartoon rage " ?

Why not take action against a muslim MP who announced as reward huge amounts of money for anyone " punishing the Danish Editor " ?

Why no punishment for ND Tiwari ?

Despite my personal misgivings , today Hindus of India have no plucky leader to rally behind save Narendra Modi.

I really look forward to the day , some gutsy Hindu puts an end to Article 370 & various other appeasement strategies. WITHOUT salivating for "consensus". Which is never going to materialise.

It is a question of our very SURVIVAL. Survival of Hindus.

hindu blog said...

It's Excellent post and also image. I liked it.
http://www.hindublog.co.in/